Quick try the dolphin, if one thing doesn't work, even if uncle Jaffa might have said it ( did I ), do something different.
APH get every fin you have that works in that board and try them all out.
If a rule doesn't work for you, (it's a theory) discard theory and find new rule.
I've never had a complaint about 9" and so 9'8" is under 10' so you can use 9" too or go smaller for a trial but the smaller you go the more the tail is going to slide, I'm going to send you a spare fin to try since you're in Victoria, PM me after you post a picture of your fin box from above so I can see if the fin will fit.
I see the side bites are futures.
I've taken up troll hunting just for fun, instead of a rifle I'll just use a pun!